Turnout

Prep cook interview questions to ask applicants

Leer en español

This guide is for chefs, kitchen managers and owners who hire prep cooks for the morning or afternoon shift. When prep goes wrong, nobody sees it until service: the line runs out of pico at 12:15, yesterday's rice never got cold enough, or every chicken portion is a different size. A good prep cook works fast without skipping steps, and that does not show up on an application.

Plan on about 15 minutes for the six questions, plus five for a knife test if you have a cutting board and an onion handy. Each question below has what a good answer sounds like and a red flag to listen for.

Six questions to ask every prep cook applicant

  1. What did a normal prep day look like at your last job? What did you cut, cook or portion, and what equipment did you use?

    Why ask
    Prep can mean anything from washing lettuce to breaking down whole chickens and making sauces from scratch. You need to know which end of that they have worked.
    A good answer
    Specific tasks and tools, like "I worked off the prep list from 6 am, diced onions and peppers for salsa, ran the slicer for deli meat, made rice and beans in batches and portioned chicken by weight."
    Red flag
    Only says "I helped in the kitchen" and cannot name one thing they made from start to finish.
  2. It's 10:15, lunch opens at 11, you still have eight items on your prep list, and the line cook says they need more pico right now. What do you do?

    Why ask
    A prep cook has to put the work in order without someone standing over them. This shows whether they know what the line needs first.
    A good answer
    Makes the pico first, then the items the line burns through at opening, and pushes slow jobs like tomorrow's stock to after lunch. By 10:45 they tell the chef what will not be ready.
    Red flag
    Keeps working the list from top to bottom and tells the line cook to wait.
  3. Prep starts at 6 am, Monday through Saturday. Which of those mornings can you work, and can you stay past 2 if a delivery comes in late?

    Why ask
    Prep runs on early mornings, and a late prep cook means a late lunch. Ask about the exact days and hours you need covered.
    A good answer
    Commits to specific mornings, like "I can do 6 am every day but Wednesday, and I can stay late if you tell me the day before."
    Red flag
    Wants to start at 9 or 10 for a job you listed as a 6 am start.
  4. How will you get here by 6 in the morning, and how long does the trip take you?

    Why ask
    A 6 am start is the first thing to slip when someone's ride is shaky, and early buses do not run everywhere.
    A good answer
    Knows the route and the time, like "I drive, about 25 minutes, and I leave at 5:20 so I have time to change."
    Red flag
    Has not checked whether their bus runs early enough to get them here by 6.
  5. You just made a big pot of chili for tomorrow. How do you cool it down and store it?

    Why ask
    Cooling food too slowly is a classic way kitchens make people sick, and it happens in prep, not on the line. This one question tells you if they were trained.
    A good answer
    Splits it into shallow pans and uses an ice bath or ice wand to get it from 135°F to 70°F within 2 hours and to 41°F within 4 more. Then covers it, labels it with the name and date, and uses the oldest batch first.
    Red flag
    Leaves the full pot on the counter overnight or puts the whole stockpot straight into the walk-in.
  6. If we hired you this week, what day could you start? Do you need to give notice somewhere or pick up anything for the job first, like kitchen shoes or a food handler card?

    Why ask
    Some people owe their current job a week of notice, need a food handler card or have to buy kitchen shoes. Better to hear it now than on their first morning.
    A good answer
    A clear date and a short list, like "Monday, and I just need to buy non-slip shoes this weekend because I already have my food handler card."
    Red flag
    Cannot give you a date, or the date moves every time you ask.

Quick yes or no questions before the interview

Ask these by text or on the phone. A no on any of them saves you both an interview.

Questions not to ask

Keep every question about the job. Do not ask about age, religion, health or disability, pregnancy, marital status or children, or where someone is from. If you need to know whether someone can work in the US, ask only whether they are legally authorized to work in the United States. EEOC: prohibited practices

Questions owners ask

Should I give prep cook applicants a knife test?
Yes. It takes five minutes and tells you more than most of the interview. Give them an onion, a pepper and a cutting board with a damp towel under it, and ask for a medium dice. Watch how they hold the knife and the food, how even the pieces are and whether they clean up when they finish.
Can I move a dishwasher up to prep cook?
Yes, and it often works out well. A dishwasher who wants to move up already knows your kitchen, your walk-in and your chef. Give them a few prep tasks on slow afternoons and teach your recipes one at a time. Move them up when they can finish a prep list without help.
What should a new prep cook know on day one, and what can I teach?
On day one you want safe knife habits, the food safety basics and someone who follows a prep list and a recipe exactly. Your recipes, your portion sizes and your par levels you can teach in the first couple of weeks.