Server interview questions to ask applicants
Leer en españolThis guide is for restaurant owners, general managers and floor managers who hire servers. Almost everyone interviews well for a server job, because talking to people is the job. What a friendly interview will not show you is whether they can run five tables at once, remember an allergy and still be pleasant at 9 pm on a Saturday.
Give yourself about 15 minutes for the six questions below. Listen for real details from past shifts instead of lines like "I'm a people person." If you like what you hear, have them shadow one of your servers for part of a dinner shift, paid, before you decide.
Six questions to ask every server applicant
Tell me about your last serving job. What kind of restaurant was it, how many tables did you have in your section, and which POS did you use?
- Why ask
- Running four tables at a diner and six tables at a steakhouse with a wine list are different jobs. The POS question tells you how much training they will need on day one.
- A good answer
- Specific numbers and tools, like "Two years at a Tex-Mex place, five or six four-tops on a Friday, Toast for the POS, and I took my own drink orders to the bar."
- Red flag
- Cannot say how many tables they had or how they rang in an order.
It's Friday at 7:30 and you're in the weeds. One table wants to order, another needs their check, and a guest says their steak came out well done when they ordered medium rare. What do you do, and in what order?
- Why ask
- Every server gets buried sometimes. You want to hear that they let each table know they have been seen and fix the food problem first, because a re-fire takes the longest.
- A good answer
- Tells each table "I'll be right with you" on the way past, takes the steak back and tells the kitchen or the manager right away, drops the check, then takes the order. If they are still behind, they ask another server or the manager for a hand.
- Red flag
- Blames the kitchen in front of the guest or argues about how the steak was ordered.
Our busiest shifts are Friday and Saturday dinner and Sunday brunch, and we schedule doubles on Sundays. Which of those can you work, and how many shifts a week do you want?
- Why ask
- Most servers want the busy shifts because that is where the tips are, but some only want lunches. Better to find out now than when you write your first schedule.
- A good answer
- Clear days and a number, like "Friday and Saturday dinner for sure, Sunday doubles every other week, four or five shifts total."
- Red flag
- Says they are open to anything, then turns down every weekend shift you mention.
How long does it take you to get here? And if you can't make a shift, how do you handle it?
- Why ask
- Servers trade shifts all the time. A good one finds their own cover and tells the manager, so you are not short a section on a Saturday.
- A good answer
- A short, steady commute and a plan, like "15 minutes by car. If I can't make it, I post the shift in the team's scheduling app, find someone to pick it up and tell the manager who is covering."
- Red flag
- Thinks a text to the manager 20 minutes before the shift is enough notice.
A guest tells you they have a peanut allergy. What do you do from that moment until their food reaches the table?
- Why ask
- With allergies, one mistake by a server can send a guest to the hospital. A trained server never guesses about ingredients.
- A good answer
- Puts the allergy in the POS and on the ticket, tells the kitchen or the manager in person, and asks about fryer oil, sauces and garnishes instead of guessing. Then they carry that plate out themselves.
- Red flag
- Would point the guest to the dishes without nuts on the menu and leave it at that.
If we offer you the job, when could you start training? New servers here shadow for two or three shifts before they get their own section. Do you have a current TABC certificate and a food handler card?
- Why ask
- Training shifts have to fit your schedule. If you serve alcohol, you will want a TABC certificate on file before they pour or carry a single drink.
- A good answer
- A date and the paperwork, like "I can shadow Tuesday and Wednesday dinner next week. I have my TABC and my food handler card, I just need black non-slip shoes."
- Red flag
- Wants their own section on a Saturday without a single training shift.
Quick yes or no questions before the interview
Ask these by text or on the phone. A no on any of them saves you both an interview.
- Can you work Friday and Saturday dinner shifts and Sunday brunch?
- Do you have at least six months of experience as a server in a sit-down restaurant?
- Do you have a current TABC seller-server certificate, or will you get one before your first shift?
- The job means being on your feet all shift and carrying trays up to 25 lb. Can you perform the essential functions of this job, with or without reasonable accommodation?
Questions not to ask
Keep every question about the job. Do not ask about age, religion, health or disability, pregnancy, marital status or children, or where someone is from. If you need to know whether someone can work in the US, ask only whether they are legally authorized to work in the United States. EEOC: prohibited practices
Questions owners ask
- Do servers in Texas need TABC certification?
- Texas law does not require each server to hold one, but many restaurants that serve alcohol make it a condition of the job. The reason is the TABC safe harbor rule, which can keep the TABC from taking action against your license when an employee serves a minor or an intoxicated guest. One of its conditions is that everyone who serves alcohol, and the managers over them, is certified within 30 days of hire. The certificate is good for two years, so check the date on it.
- Should I hire a server with no experience?
- For a slow lunch shift or a casual spot, a friendly person who learns fast can work out. For busy weekend dinners, start new people as a busser, food runner or host so they learn your menu and your floor before they get a section. Either way, quiz them on the menu during training before you hand them tables.
- How can I test a server during the interview?
- Hand them your menu for two minutes, then ask them to describe one dish and suggest a drink or appetizer to go with it. Play a guest who cannot decide or is unhappy with their food, and watch how they respond. Also notice how they treat your host and your cooks on the way in and out, because that is how they will treat their coworkers.